Sherman Alexie
portrays the deep longing of young men to be warriors in several of his stories
as they have grown to understand the honor of being a warrior and experience
the human desire to be needed.
Nearly every
little boy in our society, at some point in his childhood, wants to be a fire
fighter when he grows up. Perhaps some
want to be an astronaut or the President of the United States! Our society has taught the younger generation
that all of these professions are noble and heroic (and of course they
are). Little boys dream of that
recognition and hope of fame.
I feel like
this same dream and hope can be seen in the young Native American men. These young men have heard stories about
warriors and their courageous adventures and lives. They dream about being as great as the men
they’ve heard about for years. For
example, in the second story of the book, Victor is having a vision about
stealing horses. He says, “I needed one
of their ponies. I needed to be a hero and earn my name” (15). In “Indian Education,” Junior’s “little
warrior inside [him] roared to life” one day at school when students were
picking on him and he “knocked Frenchy to the ground” and beat him up
(172). All the young men want to
“receive their true names, their adult names” (20). There are so many examples of the young men
dreaming of being a warrior.
So why do they
want this fame and recognition? I think
they want it because they believe they will live a better, happier life with
it. In Native American culture, “the
warrior class was the most highly respected class of society” (“Native
American”). People honored and praised
them with traditional celebrations and ceremonies. It is a very prestigious position to be
in. Most of the Indians in Alexie’s book
however, seem to be poor and uneducated.
They probably thought they had a very unimportant life and that no one
really appreciated them. This may not be
the case for some Indians, but that is the idea I get from Alexie’s
descriptions of life on the reservations.
Therefore, knowing about the great lives of warriors and all the fame
and recognition that come along with being a warrior, the young men are
naturally attracted to that kind of life that they themselves have never
had. They want to be important just
like the little boys we know who want to be fire fighters when they grow
up. Humans have a strong, natural desire
to be loved and needed and that is exactly what is happening here.
There is one
problem, however. The characters discuss
airplanes and higher technology equipment so I believe the story is set in the
later 20th century. It may be
a little hard for the young men to go out and kill a large animal or steal
something to earn their adult name. In
the stories of warriors that these young men have heard, the warriors lived in
a time of little civilization where they traveled the land with the animals and
fought to survive. They had a better
opportunity to become a warrior. In the
late 20th century, with towns and private property and laws, it is a
little harder for these young men to fulfill their dreams of becoming a great
warrior. Perhaps this is why they view
basketball as such an amazing skill. It
is one of the few things they can do to gain warrior status. In fact, Norma even states in her newspaper
article about Junior’s game winning move, that “…Junior has earned a couple points more on the Warrior Scale”
(206). But back to the point, there are
not many chances for these Indians to become true warriors. While they dream so passionately of becoming
a warrior, their surroundings and the present world hinder this desire.
As Thomas
explains in one of his stories, “‘We are all given one thing by which our lives
are measured, one determination’” (72).
I feel like all the young Native American men would agree with this and
want their one determination to be something extraordinary that will prove
their warrior status and improve their lives.
Work Cited:
“Native American
Indians Warriors”. Country Facts: The
World at Your Fingertips. Country Facts and Information, 2004. Web. 23
Sept. 2012. <http://www.kwintessential.co.uk/articles/usa/Native-American-Indians-Warriors/2283>.
Amy, I love what you said about the kids wanting to be heroes, and that we have a "desire to be loved and needed". I really think that is what drives the human race. I think we do everything in response to our beliefs that we are loved and/or needed. Do you think this desire might be the reason why so many Native Americans drink on the reservation? We tend to forget that everybody we meet is attempting to adjust, fit in, feel needed, in society.
ReplyDeleteAmy, I really enjoyed reading your post and your interpretation of the prompt. I agree that the story being set in the 20th century makes it more difficult to become a warrior however I believe the way in which one becomes a warrior has changed. You defined becoming a warrior by going “out and kill a large animal or steal something to earn their adult name.” I believe this definition is no longer relevant to the time period the book was written and the era we live in today. In our world today, warriors can be defined as a soldier or as “a person who shows or has shown great vigor, courage, or aggressiveness, as in politics or athletics” (Dictionary.com). A good example of modern day warriors based off the definition would be soldiers who served in WWII and the Gulf Wars. Going off the second part of the definition, another example of a warrior could be doctors who are working to cure cancer or athletes who through all odds made it to the professional level and use their status to help others. This is just another interpretation of a warrior that is more relevant to our world today and goes along with the theme of basketball being a way to earn warrior status in Sherman Alexie’s novel.
ReplyDeleteGood point Kelly! Thanks for that interpretation. I think even with this more current description of a warrior, it is still hard for the men to become warriors. Of course, they could succeed if they wanted to, as some young men have, but with the modern American society out casting the Native Americans so much, it may be hard for them to become a warrior in the American world. We see in the story about schooling that the Indians are taken to white schools to become better educated but some teachers discriminate against them there. Sadly, the Native Americans don't feel like they truly have a place in the American society. Therefore, it may be hard for them to become active in politics, or medicine or other warrior worthy professions.
ReplyDeleteRebecca, I think the desire to be loved is probably one of the reasons for drinking on the reservation. When one drinks, they can trick themselves into thinking that they are living the perfect life. They are temporarily happy.
Amy, I like how you pointed out how hard it would be today to follow the notions of what it meant to be a warrior in the past in Native American culture.
ReplyDeleteKelly, I think you bring up a valuable point in how we view a warrior in today's society. I feel like the boys on the reservation still fantasize about being a warrior (by stealing horses) because the feel like they are bound to life on the reservation.
They see basketball as their only way out which is why basketball plays such a significant role throughout the book. I think alcohol is a form of escapism for the people on the reservation, it allows them to get away from the struggles they face in their daily lives.
Lydia, I love that you said the boys feel bound to life on the reservation. That perfectly describes what I was trying to get across! Thank you!
ReplyDeleteDo you agree with the statement “‘We are all given one thing by which our lives are measured, one determination'” (72) like some Indian's do? Or do you think many small things may add up to result in a great life?
Amy, I believe that many things make up how great their life is. An example is how some individuals may measure life through their successful careers. Some may say the CEO of a company is as accomplished but if you look at how they got there you might look at them differently. The CEO, in the best case scenario, may have been truthful and received this position in a moral manner but there are many people who step over and betray many individuals to get to the higher standing. Is the person that destroys the other individual’s lives really living a great life? Maybe in their eyes, but some may say that this person’s life is full of deceit not success. Some people measure life by the number of people who care for them, the amount of lives they have changed, and etc. A lifetime cannot be measured by one thing just like a person can’t be measured by one action.
ReplyDelete